Skip to main content

Atalaw Solicitors

If your tenant has stopped paying rent, you can forfeit a commercial lease only where the lease gives you a right of re-entry, and you can do it in 2 ways. You can change the locks on empty premises, or you can issue a court claim for possession. The alternative is commercial rent arrears recovery, known as CRAR, which lets a certificated enforcement agent take and sell the tenant’s goods without ending the lease. If you are the tenant, you usually have a short window to pay, negotiate or ask the court for relief, so the first few days matter most.

This guide explains how each route works, what it costs, where landlords go wrong and what tenants can do before the locks change. It covers England and Wales and it is general information, not advice on your particular lease.

What does forfeiture of a commercial lease mean?

Forfeiture is a landlord’s right to bring a commercial lease to an end early because the tenant has breached it, most often by not paying rent. The right is not automatic. It must be written into the lease, usually as a proviso for re-entry, and the landlord has to take a clear step to use it, either by re-entering the premises or by issuing a possession claim.

Most commercial leases allow forfeiture if rent is a set number of days late, often 14 or 21, whether or not it has been formally demanded. Check that wording first, because a landlord who cannot point to the clause cannot forfeit.

Other breaches work differently. If the problem is unauthorised alterations, a change of use or disrepair, section 146 of the Law of Property Act 1925 requires the landlord to serve a notice that specifies the breach, asks for it to be put right where that is possible and asks for compensation. The tenant must then be given a reasonable time to respond. That notice is not needed for unpaid rent, which is why rent arrears are the most common trigger.

Forfeiture also ends a tenancy that might otherwise have renewal rights, so it matters if you are weighing up renewing a business lease under the 1954 Act.

Forfeiture by peaceable re-entry

Peaceable re-entry means the landlord, usually through an enforcement agent, enters empty commercial premises and changes the locks without going to court. It only works if nobody is inside, no force is used against anyone and no part of the building is lived in. It is quick and cheap, but a mistake can leave the landlord facing a claim for wrongful forfeiture or trespass.

The residential point catches people out. Many North London shops have a flat above them. If anyone lawfully lives in any part of the premises, the Protection from Eviction Act 1977 means the landlord cannot simply change the locks, and trying to do so can be a criminal offence. In that situation the court route is the only safe option.

Landlords also need to avoid waiving the right. Demanding or accepting rent that fell due after the breach can be treated as accepting that the lease continues. If you are the landlord, stop all rent demands and stop taking payments until you have decided what to do. If you are the tenant, remember that this is the landlord’s problem, not a loophole you should plan around.

Forfeiture through the courts

A possession claim takes longer, but it is the safer choice when the premises are occupied, there is a subtenant, the arrears are disputed or there is any residential element. The claim follows Part 55 of the Civil Procedure Rules, and the landlord usually asks for the arrears and costs as well.

In a county court claim for forfeiture based on unpaid rent, you can bring the claim to an end by paying all the arrears and the landlord’s costs at least 5 clear days before the hearing date. If the court makes a possession order, it must give you at least 4 weeks to pay, and you can still apply for relief for 6 months after the landlord recovers possession.

Those protections come from section 138 of the County Courts Act 1984. They apply to claims for non-payment of rent, and the 5 day rule falls away if the landlord also claims forfeiture on another ground in the same claim. A tenant should not assume it applies without checking how the claim is framed.

Relief from forfeiture

Relief from forfeiture is the tenant’s right to ask the court to reinstate a lease the landlord has ended or is trying to end. For rent arrears, the court will normally expect you to pay the arrears and the landlord’s costs, and to apply quickly. There is no fixed limit after peaceable re-entry, but courts treat 6 months as a guide and delay counts against you.

If relief is granted, the lease carries on as though it had never ended, usually on conditions such as paying by a set date. Subtenants and mortgagees can apply too, and a subtenant can ask the court to vest a new lease in them directly. That is worth knowing if you sublet part of your unit.

What is commercial rent arrears recovery (CRAR)?

CRAR is a statutory process that lets a landlord recover unpaid rent by instructing a certificated enforcement agent to take control of the tenant’s goods and sell them. It needs a written lease of commercial premises, at least 7 days’ net unpaid rent and a notice of enforcement that gives the tenant at least 7 clear days.

The detailed conditions sit in section 77 of the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007. The rent must be certain or capable of being calculated, and the 7 days’ rent threshold must be met both when the notice is given and when goods are first taken. Any set-off the tenant is legally entitled to claim reduces the figure.

These points decide whether CRAR is available.

  • Only Rent Can Be Recovered, So Service Charge And Insurance Count Only If The Lease Reserves Them As Rent
  • Only An Enforcement Agent Can Act, And The Landlord Must Authorise Them In Writing
  • Only The Tenant’s Own Goods Can Be Taken, Not Goods Owned By Someone Else
  • The Premises Must Be Commercial, So Any Residential Use Rules It Out
  • Agents Must Take Control Of Goods Within 12 Months Of The Notice

If the unit has a subtenant, the landlord can serve a notice requiring the subtenant to pay rent directly to the landlord until the arrears are cleared. That notice takes effect 14 clear days after it is served.

Arrears that qualify as protected rent debts under the Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Act 2022 cannot be enforced through CRAR, so check the dates if your arrears go back to the pandemic closures.

CRAR does not end the lease, and taking steps under it is generally treated as treating the lease as continuing. That usually costs a landlord the right to forfeit for the same arrears, so decide which route you want before you instruct anyone.

The enforcement agent’s fees are set by regulation and are added to what the tenant owes. The current figures, in force since 1 May 2026, are in the Taking Control of Goods (Fees) Regulations 2014.

StageFixed FeePercentage Fee
Compliance stage£79None
Enforcement stage£2477.5% of the sum above £1,900
Sale or disposal stage£1167.5% of the sum above £1,900

Most tenants pay or agree a plan at the compliance stage, once the notice arrives, because the fees only climb if the process continues. That is also the point at which a landlord has the most leverage for the least cost.

Forfeiture, CRAR or a court claim: which should a landlord choose?

It depends on what you want. If you want the unit back, you forfeit. If you want the money and the tenant is worth keeping, you use CRAR or a claim. Forfeiture is a blunt tool, because an empty unit can leave you paying empty property costs such as business rates and insurance while you look for a new tenant.

RouteEnds The LeaseWorks Best WhenMain Risk
Peaceable re-entryYesThe unit is empty, wholly commercial and the arrears are clearWrongful forfeiture or trespass claim, and relief applications
Court possession claimYes, on the orderThe unit is occupied, sublet or the debt is disputedSlower and costs more, and the tenant can pay to stop it
CRARNoThe tenant has goods of value and you want the rent, not the unitNotice gives the tenant warning, and the goods may be worth little
Money claim or statutory demandNoThe tenant is a company or individual with assets, or a guarantor existsTakes time, and enforcement after judgment is a separate step

A money claim for the arrears is often combined with a call on any rent deposit or guarantor. If a director signed a guarantee, our guide to recovering a debt from a director who signed a personal guarantee sets out what to check. Where the tenant is an individual who owes £5,000 or more, a statutory demand is another option, but not where the debt is genuinely disputed. And once you have judgment, you may need to enforce a county court judgment separately.

If you are weighing these options, a commercial lease solicitor in London can check the clause, the notice history and whether you have already waived the right. For the money side, specialist debt recovery solicitors can take over the claim and enforcement.

What can a tenant do before the locks change?

Act as soon as the first demand arrives. Silence and late replies tend to push landlords towards forfeiture. A landlord who hears nothing has little reason to wait.

  • Read The Lease For The Forfeiture Clause And Any Grace Period
  • Pay What You Can And Put A Written Plan To The Landlord
  • Check For Set-Offs Or Charges You Dispute
  • Keep Proof Of Ownership For Leased Or Financed Equipment
  • Tell Any Guarantor Or Subtenant Early
  • Take Advice Before You Ignore A Notice

As an illustration, imagine a café that misses a quarter’s rent after a slow winter. If the owner replies within days with part payment and a dated plan, the landlord has a reason to keep the tenant and the lease stays intact. If the owner says nothing for 3 weeks, the landlord may serve a CRAR notice or look at the locks. The same business, the same debt, a very different position.

If you are locked out, do not force your way back in. Take advice that day, because the court’s attitude to relief depends heavily on how quickly and how reasonably you act. Our civil litigation solicitors in London act on relief applications and wrongful forfeiture claims.

Mistakes landlords make with forfeiture

The usual errors are procedural, and they are the ones a tenant’s solicitor looks for first.

  • Relying On A Lease That Has No Right Of Re-Entry
  • Accepting Or Demanding Rent After The Breach And Waiving The Right
  • Changing The Locks While Anyone Is Inside Or Living On The Premises
  • Forgetting The Section 146 Notice For Breaches Other Than Rent
  • Ignoring Subtenants Who Can Apply For Relief

Our firm acts for both landlords and tenants on forfeiture, relief from forfeiture and unpaid commercial rent, so we see both sides of these disputes. If you also have a mix of residential and commercial lettings, our landlord and tenant solicitors can advise on which rules apply to each unit.

Frequently asked questions

Can a landlord forfeit a commercial lease without going to court?

Yes, but only by peaceable re-entry. The landlord must have a right of re-entry in the lease, the premises must be empty and wholly commercial and no force can be used. If anything goes wrong, the tenant can claim wrongful forfeiture or apply for relief, so many landlords prefer a court claim.

Does a landlord have to give notice before forfeiting for unpaid rent?

Not under the statute. Section 146 notices apply to other breaches, not rent. Most leases also say the landlord can forfeit once rent is a set number of days late, whether or not it has been formally demanded. Check the exact clause, because the wording varies between leases.

How long does a tenant have to apply for relief from forfeiture?

After a court possession order for unpaid rent, you have 6 months from the date the landlord recovers possession. After peaceable re-entry there is no fixed statutory limit, but courts treat 6 months as a guide and expect you to act quickly.

How much notice does a landlord need to give before using CRAR?

The enforcement agent must give the tenant a notice of enforcement with at least 7 clear days before taking control of goods. The landlord must also be owed at least 7 days’ net unpaid rent both when notice is given and when goods are first taken.

Can a landlord use CRAR and forfeit the lease?

Usually not for the same arrears. CRAR treats the lease as continuing, and that generally costs the landlord the right to forfeit for those arrears. A landlord who wants the unit back should decide on forfeiture first and avoid steps that affirm the lease.

Speak to a solicitor before you act

Forfeiture, CRAR and a court claim all carry risks, and the right choice depends on your lease, the building and the tenant. If you are a landlord weighing your options, or a tenant who has received a demand or found the locks changed, contact our team. Call 020 3581 9293 or email info@atalawsolicitors.com and we will tell you where you stand and what to do next.

Atalaw Solicitors
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful. For further information click here.